Put gifts from every shop on one list, send one link, and let friends claim items in secret.
Free to use. Your friends don't need an account.
A wishlist that lives inside a single store works best when everything you want is sold there. Real wishes are messier: a pair of boots from a small shop, a board game from the local store, a book from somewhere else entirely.
plzly is a wishlist app that isn't tied to any shop. You paste a link, plzly fills in what it can, and the item joins one list that your friends and family can open in a browser.
Add products from any online shop. plzly pulls in the name, price and photo, and you can edit anything it gets wrong. The browser extension adds an item in one click while you shop.
Send one link. Anyone can open your list, see what's still available, and claim a gift without creating an account.
You see which gifts are claimed, never who claimed them. Everyone else sees an item is taken, so there are no double-buys.
If every gift on your list comes from one shop and everyone you share it with already has an account there, that shop's own list works fine. plzly is for when your wishes, or your friends, don't fit inside one store.