Gift exchange ideas: six formats and when to use them

Not every group wants the same kind of gift swap. Here is how the popular formats compare, so you can pick one that suits your family, friends or office.

Secret Santa

Everyone draws a name and buys one gift for that person, keeping their identity secret. Best for: offices, families and friends who want a simple, low-cost exchange. Add wishlists, and nobody has to guess. See the Secret Santa rules and use the free generator.

Kris Kringle

In some countries, including Australia and New Zealand, a Secret Santa style exchange is called a Kris Kringle. The format and the rules are the same: draw a name, buy a gift, and keep it secret until the exchange. Our Secret Santa tools work for it too.

White elephant

Everyone brings one wrapped gift, and players take turns opening a gift or stealing one that is already open. Best for: larger groups and parties where you want laughs and a bit of friendly rivalry. Read the white elephant rules and shuffle the turn order with the number generator.

Yankee swap

A close relative of white elephant. The name and the rules vary by region and family, but it is a wrapped-gift game with stealing. Check the rules with your group before you start. The white elephant guide above covers the common variations.

Book exchange

Everyone wraps a book they love, and the group swaps in turns, by drawing or stealing. Best for: book clubs and friends who enjoy reading. Add a note inside the cover to explain why you picked it.

Wishlist exchange

Everyone makes a wishlist and shares the link, and each person buys a gift from someone's list. Because friends claim items in secret, nobody buys the same thing twice. Best for: families and groups spread across towns or countries. You can make a Christmas wishlist in a few minutes.

How to choose

  • Want the lowest effort? Secret Santa.
  • Want a lively party game? White elephant or Yankee swap.
  • Want everyone to get something they chose? A wishlist exchange, or Secret Santa with wishlists.
  • Group far apart? Secret Santa or a wishlist exchange, with a shipping deadline.

Skip the guessing

Draw names in your browser for free, then let everyone make a wishlist so each Santa knows what to buy.

Free Secret Santa generator Make a wishlist

Frequently asked questions

What is the best gift exchange for a large group?
Secret Santa scales well, because each person buys only one gift. White elephant is more fun in larger groups, since more gifts means more stealing, but it takes longer to play.
What gift exchange works for people who live far apart?
Secret Santa with wishlists works well remotely: names are drawn online, and each person ships a gift to their match. White elephant is harder to run remotely.
What is a Kris Kringle?
Kris Kringle is the name used in some countries, such as Australia and New Zealand, for a Secret Santa style exchange where everyone buys one gift for a person they drew.
How do we avoid awkward or unwanted gifts?
Use wishlists. When everyone shares a list, the person buying can choose something the recipient picked for themselves.